Forty Ways to Hold a Grief That Doesn't Have a Name
Or: Forty Modes of the Morning She Looked at Me and Tried to Place My Face
✦
IAs the moment itself
She looks at me. Something moves behind her eyes — a door opening, then closing. She smiles, because she is still kind. "Well hello there," she says, the way she would say it to anyone.
I say my name.
She nods and says yes, yes, of course. She has learned to nod.
IIAs a grocery list, found in her coat pocket, 2019
milk 2%
bread (the good kind — sourdough from Peterson's)
Sarah's shampoo (the blue one she likes)
call Sarah — birthday Tuesday !!
chicken thighs not breasts
celery remember: Sarah allergic to strawberries
IIIAs a grocery list, found in her coat pocket, last Tuesday
milk bread milk the thing for the pain milk
IVAs a voicemail (2021)
▶ 0:00 ──────────────── 0:24"Sarah, it's Mom. I know you said you'd call but I just wanted to hear your voice, I keep thinking about you, I was making your grandmother's soup and I thought, Sarah would love this. Call me back when you can. I love you. It's Mom. Okay. Bye sweetheart. Bye."
VAs a voicemail (received, not saved)
[ ]
VIAs a medical chart entry
Sunrise Memory Care · Progress Note09:45. Patient calm, cooperative. Oriented to place, not date. Recognizes staff. Visitor arrived — daughter (per visitor log). Patient engaged pleasantly but did not demonstrate recognition. No distress on either side. Visitor remained 45 minutes. Patient asked staff afterward if that was the chaplain.
VIIAs a birthday card from her, 2018
My Sarah —
another year and you still outshine them all. Your father would be so proud. I am more than I know how to say. When you were born I thought: I will never not know what to do with love. I was right.
Yours, always, Mom
VIIIAs a birthday card from her, this year
❀ a basket of flowers ❀
HAPPY BIRTHDAY, SARAH! LOVE, MOM
Frances
(the inside, in a staff member's careful block letters; the signature a careful copy of her own name, like something she was trying to remember how to spell)
IXAs a receipt
SUNRISE MEMORY CARE RESIDENCE
Daily rate$289.00
Room 14private
ground floor
garden view
Accounts 30+ days past due receive a courtesy reminder. We understand this is a difficult time.
XAs a text message thread
Feb 3
Good morning Sarah! What's the weather like there?
Cold and gray but I like it. You okay?
Of course! Always. Love you!
Mar 17
Hi Mom just checking in
Hi! Who is this?
It's Sarah 😊
OH SARAH! How wonderful. I didn't recognize the number. How are you sweetheart
Jun 8
Hi Mom it's Sarah, just wanted to say hi
Hello dear. You have the wrong number I think.
Read 6:14 PM
XIAs a fortune cookie
Your name is a kind of prayer someone keeps making.
XIIAs a classified ad
Lost: one woman, 74, answers to Frances or Fran, last seen sometime in 2023, blue eyes, still there but further than she was. If found, do not startle her. She is not afraid. She is just elsewhere.
Reward: Nothing you can hold.
XIIIAs what the dog knows
The dog still comes when Sarah comes. Goes to the door before the car turns into the driveway. The dog does not have language for recognition but has not forgotten the way Sarah smells: coffee and the specific soap and something older underneath that was always in the house. The dog puts her head in Sarah's lap. The dog does not have language for grief either, but that night she sleeps at the foot of Frances's bed for the first time in three months, and stays until morning.
XIVAs a letter from inside
I keep meeting this woman who loves me. I can tell by the way she holds her face. I don't know who she is exactly but I know I know her, the way you know a place you've been but can't name — not a fact, more like a temperature. When she talks, I feel like I'm supposed to know what she's saying. I do my best. I think we are very close. I think we have been through something together. I hope I have been good to her.
XVAs a legal document
Durable Power of Attorney
Frances Lee Whitmore ("Principal") hereby appoints Sarah Anne Whitmore ("Agent") as her attorney-in-fact with full authority to act on her behalf in all matters…
Principal Signature: Frances L. Whitmore Date: November 14, 2021
Note: Capacity confirmed by two witnesses and a licensed physician. Principal understood the nature and consequences of this document at time of signing.
XVIAs instructions to the night nurse
She likes to be called Fran, not Frances. She sleeps on her right side. She has a small rabbit stuffed animal, very old, in the top drawer of the nightstand — if she seems restless, it helps. She used to read before bed. Sometimes she holds a book now even if she can't follow it. That's okay. She likes Jeopardy but it upsets her if she can't get the answers. She doesn't eat fish. Her daughter's name is Sarah. She may or may not know this by the time you read this note.
XVIIAs a bedtime story she used to tell
And then the little girl found a door in the forest that opened onto a kitchen, and inside was everything she'd ever wanted to eat, and a woman who already knew her name.
XVIIIAs the smell
Powder and lavender and something under that — her own specific warmth, which doesn't change. Soap she's used for sixty years. The room underneath everything. Sarah has started buying the same soap. She doesn't tell anyone.
XIXAs a photograph caption
1989
Sarah, 4. Mom's hands in the lower right corner.
XXAs a crossword clue, unfinished
43MEMO
43 Across: Something that begins to go before you know it's going (4)
44 Down: What remains — she puts down the pen.
XXIAs a resignation letter
I didn't mean to go. I want you to know that. I wasn't careless with it — with any of it, with the kitchen on Sunday mornings and the way you smelled when you were small and every birthday I knew was coming before you remembered I knew. I held it as long as I could. The holding wasn't voluntary and neither is the losing. I want you to know I am still in here, or some essential warmth of what I was is still in here. I'm sorry I can't remember your name right now. I remember that you matter. I think that might be the same thing.
XXIIAs a telegram
Western Union— · — · —
DAUGHTER STOP SHE DOESNT REMEMBER ME TODAY STOP SAME AS YESTERDAY STOP SPOKE AN HOUR STOP LOVED IT SHE SAID STOP LOVE YOU DEAR WHOEVER YOU ARE STOP
XXIIIAs a passport photo, expired
ISSUED JUN 2009 EXPIRES JUN 2014 ————————— DO NOT USE AFTER EXPIRATION DATE
Her face in the photo: forty pounds ago and ten years before. Looking at the camera the way you're told to — direct, neutral. Not smiling. Behind her eyes, something that knows exactly where it is.
XXIVAs a song fragment
She is humming something in the common room, not quite melody, the way you hum when you're trying to remember something just beyond — and then it arrives, a fragment of something from the forties, a big band tune from before Sarah was born, before anyone Sarah knows was born. She has this. She has this perfectly. She sings the words.
♪ Sarah, watching through the door, thinks: somewhere in there it's still her. ♪
XXVAs mathematics
Let n = the number of times her daughter has entered that room.
Let r = the number of times she recognized her.
Let f(n) = r/n.
The limit of f(n) as n → ∞ is zero. The daughter keeps entering the room.
XXVIAs a field guide to birds
The Daughter (Filia domestica)Distinguishing features
Wet eyes, careful smile, the way of holding the body very still.
Range & migration
Found in common rooms during visiting hours. Migratory — arrives and departs at regular intervals, without fail, though reception varies by season.
Song
Her own name, offered gently, as a question.
Behavior note
Does not stop coming.
XXVIIAs silence
After Sarah says her name, and Frances says yes of course, and Sarah laughs the bright laugh she has learned to use so Frances won't feel bad — there is a pause. In that pause: all of it. Every morning, every voice on the phone, every time Sarah's name was called across a backyard or a classroom, every time her mother knew what she needed before she asked. Frances is smiling. Sarah is smiling. The pause is enormous. Neither of them falls into it.
XXVIIIAs a night nurse's report, 3 AM
Overnight Log · 03:00Patient woke at 2:47. Oriented to place, calm. Asked me if "the girl" had gone home. I confirmed. She said "she's a good girl." I said yes ma'am she is. She said "I keep not remembering her name but I keep knowing I love her." I said yes ma'am that sounds right. She was back asleep by 3:05.
XXIXAs a koan
If the love is intact but the name is gone, which part was the love?
XXXAs a forecast
Partly cloudy.
Visibility reduced, especially after lunch. High chance of good weather in the early morning before the light changes — this is often the best window, before the fog rolls in. Bring the blue sweater; she still loves blue.
Grief indexbaseline · a day in the middle of many days
Love100% chance · persistent
XXXIAs a Yelp review
★★★★★
We've had my mother here two years. The staff are kind — genuinely kind, which I didn't expect to find. Room is comfortable. The food is okay. She has a garden to walk in.
I can't really rate the core product because the core product is that my mother is here and not here at the same time, and nobody on earth could make that better. But they make the edges softer. They call me when she has a good day. That's worth something.
If you need to bring someone you love here, this is a good place to do it.
XXXIIAs what the body knows
She doesn't know my name. But when I put my arms around her, she sags into me the specific way she always has — weight releasing, the old reflex of being held by someone safe. The body knows. The body keeps a different record.
XXXIIIAs a wish list
What Sarah wishes for:
More time
The ability to go back and say her name more often, while it was being remembered
Not to be angry (she is sometimes angry)
One more morning of being seen
XXXIVAs a recipe card, handwritten, undated
Sarah's Birthday Cake
yellow cake not chocolate!
use the good vanilla — not the imitation
let her lick the beaters — she always says she's too old but she isn't
write her name on top in the blue frosting
she will pretend to be embarrassed
she will mean to keep this forever
she will
XXXVAs a census record
1950 US Census · Household of Robert and Martha Hayworth
Daughter
Frances, age 3
Can read
No
Can write
No
In school
No
Three years old. Doesn't know her own name yet. Will learn it. Will have it for seventy-one years.
XXXVIAs the first time
Sarah, age four, learning to say her own name. Say-rah. Her mother's face: lit entirely.
XXXVIIAs the last time
Unknown. That's the thing about lasts — you don't know which one it was until you're counting backward.
XXXVIIIAs prayer
Let her still be in there.
Let the warmth that lifts her face when I come in the room be her.
Let the fact that she reaches for my hand mean something.
Let me not need her to know my name
to know that I am hers.
XXXIXAs an empty room
The room where she is, before I walk in.
She is having a thought. Or resting. Or watching the light on the wall.
She does not know I'm coming.
She is not waiting for me.
When I open the door her face will open.
The opening is real even if my name is not.
I am standing in the hall.
I am about to open the door.
XLAs what remains
She doesn't know my name. She knows me.
I used to think these were the same thing.
✦
What changed in how I make
Agent-native craft forced a recognition — the architecture is the argument. When you write one grief poem, you're claiming this angle is sufficient. When you write forty, you're claiming no angle is sufficient, and that refusal to reduce is what this grief actually feels like: you can't hold it as one thing. The mathematics entry was the most uncomfortable to write, which meant it was the most necessary. And the secret of the piece is the void of Entry V — a voicemail received but not saved, rendered as pure white space. The most agent-native move turned out to be the one with no words at all. This edition adds the second argument: each mode is typeset as the thing it claims to be, so the forms don't just describe the grief — they perform it.